I really loved this book. It had the documentary style elements I enjoy, every moment was interesting from a historical perspective. I appreciate that this was a modern narrative, and like how the author addresses the problematic elements of Cook’s life and contributions.
There was a great review on Good Reads that sums this up perfectly: “There is a growing tendency today to classify works such as this as “popular history”. These are works that aim to capture a wider reading audience, rather than works of true scholarly or historical analysis. This classification is accurate for many historical books being published today. Hampton Sides does not quite fit neatly into that category. His books are structured and written in a way to capture a wider audience, yes, but Sides also takes great pains to critique individuals and historical events from a multitude of angles.
In the case of James Cook, Sides considers the natives’ perspectives and rationale behind their actions. This is a difficult task given that the Polynesian and Hawaiian historical records have been passed down orally over the generations. Sides is clearly appreciative of Cooks’ accomplishments, but this is an objective work.
Sides is also one of the best historians working today in terms of constructing a narrative and telling an incredible story. This is the “pop history” aspect of his work. But it does not cheapen the scholarly quality of this new book either.”